9) Proof of Crime Patrol true stories ::: How rapists manage to get bail

She is a bad girl, hence high court grants bail to rapists:::
Sep 23 2017 : copyright with The Times of India (Bangalore)
HC grants bail to rapists for girl’s `promiscuous attitude’
Court Says Girl’s Words Reveal Perverse Streak
In an unusual order, the Punjab and Haryana high court granted bail to three convicts in the infamous blackmailing and gang-rape case of a student of OP Jindal Global University at Sonipat, observing that the woman’s statement offered an alternate conclusion of “misadventure stemming from a promiscuous attitude and a voyeuristic mind“.

 

The HC passed these orders while allowing the bail plea of the three convicts -Hardik Sikri, Karan Chabra and Vikas Garg -till the pendency of their appeal against conviction.

The HC division bench also ordered counselling of the trio at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) “for correcting their behavioural aberration“.

The bench directed that all the three convicts would be subjected to counselling by a trained AIIMS psychiatrist and “a report in that regard must be communicated to the HC indicating whether the applicants are free of their voyeuristic tendencies“. The court has also directed the three to pay Rs 10 lakh compensation, to be shared equally by them, to the survivor.

While challenging the orders, the counsel for the accused had argued that the girl’s testimony did not reveal that she was being subjected to a traumatic blackmail, rather, she came across as willing and compliant.

However, the division bench of Justice Mahesh Grover and Justice Raj Shekhar Atri, observed: “We are conscious of the fact that allegations of the victim regarding her being threatened into submission and blackmail lends sufficient diabolism to the offence, but a careful examination of her statement again offers an alternate conclusion of misad venture stemming from a promiscuous attitude and a voyeuristic mind.“

The bench went on to observe, “She states that `he (one of the accused, Hardik) then sent his own nude pictures and coaxed me into sending my own nude pictures’. The perverse streak in both is also revealed from her admission that a sex toy was suggested by Hardik and her acceptance of the same.“

The high court also observed that the testimony of the victim “does offer an alternate story of casual relationship with her friends, acquaintances, adventurism and experimentation in sexual encounters and these factors would therefore, offer a compelling reasons to consider the prayer for suspension of sentence favourably particularly when the accused themselves are young and the nar rative does not throw up gut wrenching violence, that normally precede or accompany such incidents.“

It said: “It would be a travesty if these young minds are confined to jail for an inordinate long period which would deprive them of their education, opportunity to redeem themselves and be a part of the society as normal beings“. The girl had lodged a complaint with the university on April 11, 2015, alleging the trio, final year law students of the same institition, had been blackmailing and raping her since August 2013. She alleged the accused had her objectionable photos which they used to force her to have physical relations with them.

In March this year, a Sonipat court had awarded a 20year sentence to Hardik and Karan each and a seven-year jail term to Vikas.

Times View

The court order in this case exhibits victim shaming of the worst kind. Defence counsel in rape cases often try and paint the victim as a person of loose morals. It is most unfortunate that a high court has stigmatised a victim in a similar manner.The Supreme Court has in the past said that victims of sexual crimes should not be stigmatised for their perceived morality and that a woman has the right to refuse consent to sex even if she has been promiscuous. That is as it should be. We wish the court had shown at least as much sensitivity towards the victim in this case as it has towards the accused.

Advertisements

Author: Ravikanth K.A.

I am a Rajakaluve and Lake encroachment investigator, advisor, consultant. Ravikanth is my name. I can tell you exactly which property is safe for you to buy and which one is not safe, even to be considered or given a second look, from the perspective of lake or rajakaluve or storm water drain encroachment and property demolition possibilities in the future (that will lead to your ultimate financial destruction). Below is given a brief description about my skills and the value addition that I can bring to your property purchase endeavour, when you plan to buy some property somewhere in Bangalore. Contact me on 8884284819 for appointment for a paid consultancy (on commercial terms) to get your property that you are planning to buy checked – to see if it has got any encroachment into any water body like a rajakaluve/storm water drain/naala/nala/water feeder canal or a lake etc. Even if it is in the no-construction zone, called buffer zone of a lake or a rajakaluve, as per NGT Rules and norms, you are not supposed to buy the property and if you do, you could be in trouble with demolition threats going forward (in the future) from the concerned authorities. Hence, dont by penny wise and pound foolish. Get your property checked by me before buying anything blindly anywhere in Karnataka especially in Bangalore. Contact me on 8884284819 for an expert opinion on all rajakaluve and lake encroachment investigation, advise and consultancy of any property that you wish to buy anywhere in Bangalore, both urban and rural areas (including the outskirts) of Bangalore. Connect with me – Ravikanth, to get your property papers investigated by me for encroachment related issues and also to find out how you can explore real estate opportunities with me – for advice on Real Estate Investment anywhere in Bangalore – Any Locality – Anywhere in Bangalore’s vast land mass of 8005 sq.km

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s